I have noticed an increase in LinkedIn posts criticising training. Some blame organisations for using it as the default response to every performance problem. Others argue that training does not create behavioural change. Often, the route through the post leads to the writer’s own alternative, which I completely understand. The challenge is that the argument can make training sound like one single thing – and it is not.
We humans love a label. We group complex subjects into neat categories because it makes them easier to discuss, but the label can hide the detail. Training is one of those categories. Before we decide whether it works, perhaps we should ask two more useful questions: what do we mean by training, and what problem are we expecting it to solve?
Summary
Training is not a single event or a universal cure for underperformance. The right response depends on whether the gap is in knowledge, skill, confidence, motivation or the working environment. Good development starts with diagnosis, uses the right mix of methods and gives people time to practise, apply and reinforce what they have learned.
The problem is not always training
Imagine there is a gap between the performance an organisation expects and the results someone is producing. Sending that person on a course may be the right answer, but it may also be an expensive way of avoiding the real question: why does the gap exist?
At a basic level, performance gaps tend to fall into three areas:
| The gap | What we hear | What may be needed |
| Knowledge | I do not know what | Clear information, expectations, procedures and updates |
| Skill | I do not know how | Demonstration, practice, feedback and repeated application |
| Attitude or confidence | I do not want to – or I am not sure I can | Investigation, coaching, support, motivation and psychological safety |
These gaps require different responses, yet they are frequently swept under the same training umbrella. That is when organisations spend money, employees lose time and everyone concludes that training did not work.
A knowledge gap needs clarity
A knowledge gap is usually the easiest to address. Someone may not know the process, the standard, the product or what good performance looks like. They need accurate information in a form they can use: a clear explanation, an accessible procedure, a demonstration or a timely update when something changes.
Traditional training often concentrates heavily on this area. A trainer stands at the front of a room and works through countless PowerPoint slides – or, as we sometimes call them, weapons of mass instruction. Information has been delivered, but that does not automatically mean it has been understood, remembered or applied.
A skills gap needs practice
Knowing what to do is not the same as being able to do it. Skills develop through practical application: masterclasses, real play, case studies, observation, feedback and the chance to try again. If someone is learning to manage a difficult conversation, lead a team meeting or handle a customer complaint, theory alone will not prepare them for the moment when another human being reacts in an unexpected way.
A good trainer creates opportunities for people to perform, reflect and improve. Some form of assessment may be useful, but the real test is whether the person can use the skill confidently back at work.
An attitude gap may not be an attitude problem
The attitude gap is the hardest to understand. When someone appears not to want to do a task, it is easy to decide that they are lazy, disengaged or simply the wrong person for the role. Occasionally that may be true, but in my experience the more common barrier is confidence.
They may know what to do and understand how to do it, but fear poor performance or adverse judgement. They may compare themselves with someone more experienced, worry about forgetting an important step or feel that one mistake will define them. From the outside this can look like reluctance. On the inside it may feel like self-protection.
Sheep dipping someone into a standard training programme will not resolve that. They may need coaching, encouragement, constructive feedback, a safer opportunity to practise or support from their manager. Before we prescribe, we need to diagnose.
Start with the performance, not the programme
Useful diagnosis begins with questions, not a course catalogue:
- Why is there a gap in performance?
- What is preventing the right results from being delivered consistently?
- Is the real gap knowledge, skill, confidence, motivation or something else?
- Has this always been the case, or is the drop in performance new?
- What will be different if the intervention works?
The history matters. If someone has never performed the task to the required standard, the issue may sit with their induction, initial training or access to clear guidance. The answer may be to review how the role is taught and supported. Speed is not a test of aptitude; different people need different routes and different amounts of practice to reach a consistent standard. It is also why being an expert in a subject does not automatically make someone an effective trainer.
If the dip is new, the cause may sit elsewhere. Workloads may have increased, a team may be under-resourced because of long-term absence, systems may have changed, or outside pressures may be affecting concentration and motivation. No amount of traditional training will solve a problem caused by unrealistic expectations, poor tools or a lack of capacity.
Training is an umbrella, not a single method
The word training now covers a wide range of ways to help people learn, develop and perform. Each method has a different purpose, and several may be combined when the situation calls for it.
Sometimes a blended approach works best. People might begin with a short piece of teaching, watch an experienced colleague, practise in a realistic scenario, receive coaching and then revisit the learning after they have used it. The combination should be chosen because it supports the desired result, not because it fills a day or looks impressive in a proposal.
Why one-hit wonders rarely work
One thing I have learned over the years is that one-hit wonders rarely create lasting change. A lively training day can send delegates back to work with plenty of ideas and a burst of motivation. Then business as usual returns, the inbox fills up and the new approach gradually disappears.
Sustainable improvement is more likely when learning is progressive and layered. People need opportunities to practise, review, refine and apply what they have learned. Managers may need to reinforce the new expectations, remove barriers and notice progress. The organisation must also be prepared to measure what has changed rather than treating attendance as the result.
What effective development should include
A carefully considered approach does not have to be complicated, but it should include:
- A clear diagnosis of the performance gap and its likely causes.
- Agreed outcomes linked to the organisation’s wider goals.
- Methods suited to the people, the task and the working environment.
- Practical application rather than information alone.
- Time for reflection, feedback and further practice.
- Support after the initial intervention so learning becomes normal behaviour.
- A sensible way to judge whether performance has improved.
An off-the-shelf programme may meet some needs, but it will rarely answer every question. Tailored does not mean changing a logo on the first slide. It means understanding the organisation, the people, the barriers and the results that matter, then designing an approach around them.
Training should be a catalyst, not a tick box
Training still has an important place in organisational performance, but only when we stop asking it to solve every problem. If people need more knowledge, stronger skills or greater confidence, the right development can help them deliver results that support the bigger picture. If the barrier is workload, leadership, systems, resources or culture, we need to be honest enough to address that instead.
So before deciding that training does not work – or booking another programme because it is what we have always done – perhaps the better question is: what is really preventing people from performing at their best, and what combination of support will help them move forward?
Frequently Asked Questions
What is workplace training?
Workplace training is any structured activity designed to improve the knowledge, skills or confidence people need to perform effectively. It may include teaching, coaching, mentoring, shadowing, practical workshops, e-learning, assessment or a blend of several approaches.
Why does training sometimes fail to change behaviour?
Training often disappoints when it addresses the wrong problem, relies on information without practice, or ends without reinforcement. Behavioural change is more likely when people understand why the change matters, practise the required skill, receive feedback and are supported to apply it in their everyday work.
How can you identify the real performance gap?
Start by comparing the expected result with what is happening now. Ask whether the person knows what to do, can do it, feels confident doing it and has the time, tools and support required. It is also important to establish whether the issue has always existed or has appeared recently.
Can training fix a poor attitude?
Not automatically. What looks like a poor attitude may be low confidence, unclear expectations, frustration, lack of trust, excessive workload or a genuine motivational issue. Diagnosis should come first. Training may form part of the answer, but coaching, management support or changes to the working environment may be more appropriate.
Is a one-off training course ever worthwhile?
Yes, particularly when the need is focused and the learning can be applied immediately. However, a single event is less likely to create lasting change when the subject involves complex skills or new behaviour. Follow-up, practice and reinforcement usually improve the return on the time and money invested.
What is blended learning?
Blended learning combines different development methods, such as teaching, e-learning, practical exercises, coaching and workplace application. The value comes from choosing methods that support the required outcome, rather than using variety for its own sake.